From Handshake to Binding Contract: Understanding Termsheets and Shareholder Agreements

For founders navigating their first institutional funding round, the journey from a verbal commitment to a closed deal can feel like traversing a legal maze. At the heart of this journey lie two critical documents: the Term Sheet and the Shareholders' Agreement (SHA). While both documents cover similar ground, they serve distinctly different purposes and carry different legal weights in your funding journey.

The Term Sheet: Setting the Stage

Think of a term sheet as the architectural blueprint of your deal. It outlines the key commercial and legal terms that will govern the investment, but in a relatively concise, high-level format. While generally non-binding (except for specific clauses like confidentiality and exclusivity), the term sheet serves as the foundation for all definitive agreements that follow.

Key Characteristics of Term Sheets

A term sheet typically covers fundamental aspects of the deal in broad strokes. It's meant to capture the commercial understanding between parties while leaving the minutiae for later documentation. The key elements usually include:

Investment terms, including valuation, investment amount, and instrument type, are outlined in clear, commercial language. Governance rights, board composition, and key reserved matters are specified but not exhaustively detailed. Protection rights like anti-dilution, liquidation preference, and exit rights are defined in principle but not in their full mechanical detail.

The Purpose and Limitations

Term sheets serve multiple crucial purposes in the fundraising process. They help parties align on key commercial terms early, saving time and legal costs by ensuring basic agreement before diving into detailed documentation. They also serve as instructions for lawyers drafting definitive agreements, providing a clear outline of what needs to be documented in detail.

However, term sheets have their limitations. They're intentionally brief and don't address every contingency or detail. Many terms that seem straightforward in a term sheet – like anti-dilution protection or exit rights – require extensive mechanical detail in actual implementation.

The Shareholders' Agreement: Where the Devil Lives in the Details

If the term sheet is the blueprint, the SHA is the complete construction manual. It transforms the high-level principles agreed in the term sheet into detailed, legally binding mechanisms that govern the relationship between shareholders.

From Principles to Mechanics

The SHA expands each term sheet provision into its full mechanical detail. For instance, where a term sheet might simply state "Investors will have anti-dilution protection," the SHA will specify:

• The exact formula for calculating anti-dilution adjustments
• The specific exceptions and carve-outs
• The procedural requirements for implementing adjustments
• The impact on different classes of shares
• The interaction with other rights and protections

Beyond the Term Sheet

The SHA also addresses numerous matters that typically don't appear in term sheets but are crucial for smooth company operations. These include:

Detailed Transfer Restrictions: The SHA will specify precise mechanisms for implementing transfer restrictions, including:

• Right of First Refusal (ROFR) procedures
• Tag-along implementation mechanics
• Lock-in period exceptions
• Permitted transfer conditions

Comprehensive Governance Framework: While term sheets outline basic governance rights, the SHA creates detailed operational rules covering:

• Board meeting procedures
• Voting mechanisms
• Information rights implementation
• Reserved matter processes

Dispute Resolution: The SHA includes detailed provisions for handling disagreements and deadlocks, something rarely mentioned in term sheets.

Key Differences and Interconnections

Legal Status

The term sheet serves primarily as a moral commitment and negotiation tool, while the SHA is a legally binding contract that courts will enforce.

Level of Detail

Where the term sheet might dedicate a single line to a concept like "pro-rata rights," the SHA might use several pages to address all possible scenarios and implementation mechanics.

Timing and Evolution

The term sheet represents an initial meeting of minds, while the SHA reflects the final, negotiated position after thorough legal and commercial discussion.

Critical Considerations for Founders

During Term Sheet Negotiation

1. Focus on Commercial Terms Don't get bogged down in legal details at the term sheet stage. Focus on commercial terms that materially impact your business and ownership. Remember, you'll have opportunity to negotiate details during SHA drafting.
2. Watch for Unusual Terms While most term sheet provisions have "market standard" expansions in the SHA, unusual terms might signal complicated or founder-unfriendly provisions in the final documentation.

During SHA Negotiation

1. Understand the Expansion Pay careful attention to how term sheet principles are expanded in the SHA. The mechanical details can significantly impact how rights actually work in practice.
2. Mind the Gaps Watch for new terms in the SHA that weren't mentioned in the term sheet. While some expansion is normal, material new terms should be questioned.

Conclusion: From Principles to Practice

The journey from term sheet to SHA represents the transformation of commercial understanding into legal reality. While term sheets capture the basic deal structure and commercial terms, SHAs create the detailed framework that will govern your company's operations and shareholder relationships for years to come.

Understanding this relationship helps founders navigate the documentation process more effectively. It allows you to focus on the right issues at the right time – commercial terms during term sheet negotiation, and mechanical details during SHA drafting.

Remember that while both documents are important, they serve different purposes. The term sheet gets the deal done, but the SHA makes it work. Invest time in understanding both, but save your detailed negotiating energy for the SHA, where the real impact on your company's future will be determined.

‍